Skip to Content

Broad Winged Hawk Vs Red-tailed Hawk

Birdwatching is a popular pastime for nature enthusiasts around the world, and two of the most commonly observed raptors in North America are the Broad-winged Hawk and the Red-tailed Hawk. These majestic birds of prey share many similarities, but also have distinct differences that set them apart. In this article, we will explore the characteristics, behaviors, and habitats of both species, as well as delve into some interesting trends related to these fascinating birds.

The Broad-winged Hawk (Buteo platypterus) and the Red-tailed Hawk (Buteo jamaicensis) are both members of the Buteo genus, which includes a variety of medium to large-sized hawks. While they belong to the same genus, these two species have different physical characteristics that make them easily distinguishable in the wild.

The Broad-winged Hawk is a smaller bird compared to the Red-tailed Hawk, with a wingspan of around 32-39 inches and a body length of 13-17 inches. They have a dark brown upper body with a white belly and chest, and their wings are marked with black and white bands. In contrast, the Red-tailed Hawk is larger, with a wingspan of 43-57 inches and a body length of 18-26 inches. They have a distinctive rusty-red tail, which gives them their name, and a mottled brown and white body.

In terms of behavior, both hawks are skilled hunters that primarily feed on small mammals, birds, and reptiles. They are known for their soaring flight patterns, where they use thermal currents to glide effortlessly through the air while searching for prey. Both species are also known for their loud, piercing calls that can be heard from a distance.

When it comes to habitat, the Broad-winged Hawk prefers dense forests and woodlands, where they can find ample cover and nesting sites. They are commonly found in the eastern United States and southern Canada during the breeding season, and migrate south to Central and South America for the winter. On the other hand, the Red-tailed Hawk is a more adaptable species that can be found in a variety of habitats, including grasslands, deserts, and open woodlands. They are year-round residents in many parts of North America, and can often be seen perched on telephone poles or fence posts along highways.

Now, let’s explore some interesting trends related to Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks:

1. Broad-winged Hawks are known for their impressive migration behavior, where thousands of individuals can be seen migrating together in large flocks called “kettles.” This phenomenon occurs in the fall when the hawks are heading south for the winter, and is a sight to behold for birdwatchers and nature enthusiasts.

2. Red-tailed Hawks are known for their territorial behavior, where they will fiercely defend their nesting sites from intruders. They are often seen performing aerial displays, such as soaring high in the air and diving down at high speeds to intimidate other birds or predators.

3. Broad-winged Hawks have a unique hunting strategy where they will hunt in pairs or small groups, working together to flush out prey from dense vegetation. This cooperative behavior increases their chances of success and allows them to catch more food than if they were hunting alone.

4. Red-tailed Hawks are known for their distinctive hunting technique called “stooping,” where they will dive down from a great height at incredible speeds to catch their prey by surprise. This impressive aerial maneuver requires precision and skill, and showcases the agility and power of these birds of prey.

5. Broad-winged Hawks are more elusive and secretive compared to Red-tailed Hawks, making them harder to spot in the wild. They prefer to stay hidden in dense forests and are often heard rather than seen, making them a challenge for birdwatchers to observe.

6. Red-tailed Hawks are known for their adaptability and resilience in urban environments, where they can often be seen hunting in city parks, golf courses, and suburban neighborhoods. They have learned to coexist with humans and take advantage of the abundance of prey in urban areas.

7. Both Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks are protected under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, which prohibits the hunting, capturing, or killing of these birds without a permit. This legislation has helped to conserve these species and ensure their survival for future generations to enjoy.

Now, let’s hear from some professionals in the field of ornithology about their thoughts on Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks:

1. “The Broad-winged Hawk is a fascinating species with unique migration patterns that showcase the incredible instincts and abilities of these birds. Studying their behavior during migration can provide valuable insights into their ecology and conservation needs.” – Ornithologist

2. “Red-tailed Hawks are iconic symbols of the American wilderness, with their majestic appearance and powerful hunting abilities. Their presence in urban environments highlights their adaptability and resilience in the face of human encroachment on their habitats.” – Wildlife Biologist

3. “Broad-winged Hawks are elusive and mysterious birds that prefer to stay hidden in the dense forests where they nest. Their secretive nature makes them a challenging species to study, but also adds to their allure and appeal for birdwatchers.” – Conservationist

4. “Red-tailed Hawks are top predators in their ecosystems, playing a crucial role in controlling populations of small mammals and birds. Their hunting prowess and territorial behavior make them a formidable force in the natural world, and a species worth protecting for future generations.” – Ecologist

Now, let’s address some common concerns and questions related to Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks:

1. Are Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks endangered species?

Both species are not considered endangered, but they face threats from habitat loss, pesticide use, and collisions with vehicles. Conservation efforts are underway to protect these birds and ensure their populations remain stable.

2. What is the lifespan of Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks?

Broad-winged Hawks can live up to 12 years in the wild, while Red-tailed Hawks have been known to live up to 20 years in captivity. Their lifespan in the wild is typically shorter due to predation, disease, and environmental factors.

3. Do Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks mate for life?

Both species are monogamous and will form long-term pair bonds with their mates. They will often return to the same nesting site year after year and work together to raise their young.

4. How do Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks build their nests?

Broad-winged Hawks build their nests in the branches of trees using sticks, twigs, and leaves, while Red-tailed Hawks prefer to nest in tall trees or on cliffs using a combination of sticks, grasses, and feathers.

5. What are the main threats to Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks?

The main threats to these birds include habitat loss, pesticide poisoning, collisions with man-made structures, and illegal hunting. Conservation efforts are essential to protect these species and ensure their survival.

6. How can I attract Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks to my backyard?

Providing a habitat with trees, shrubs, and open spaces can attract these birds to your backyard. Installing bird feeders with seeds and suet can also attract them, as well as offering a source of water for drinking and bathing.

7. What is the best time of year to observe Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks?

The best time to observe these birds is during the breeding season in the spring and summer, when they are actively nesting and raising their young. Fall is also a good time to see Broad-winged Hawks during their migration south.

8. How do Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks communicate with each other?

These birds communicate through a variety of vocalizations, including calls, screams, and screeches. They use these vocalizations to defend their territory, attract a mate, and warn of potential threats.

9. Are Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks at risk from climate change?

Climate change can impact these birds by altering their habitats, food sources, and migration patterns. Conservation efforts are needed to mitigate the effects of climate change on these species and ensure their survival.

10. What is the hunting behavior of Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks?

Both species are skilled hunters that use their sharp talons and beaks to catch prey. Broad-winged Hawks hunt in pairs or small groups, while Red-tailed Hawks are solitary hunters that use their powerful stooping technique to catch prey by surprise.

11. How do Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks differ in their nesting habits?

Broad-winged Hawks prefer to nest in dense forests and woodlands, while Red-tailed Hawks nest in a variety of habitats, including grasslands, deserts, and urban areas. Both species build their nests using sticks, twigs, and other materials.

12. What is the role of Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks in their ecosystems?

These birds play a crucial role as top predators in their ecosystems, controlling populations of small mammals, birds, and insects. They help to maintain the balance of their ecosystems and contribute to overall biodiversity.

13. How can I help conserve Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks?

You can help conserve these birds by supporting habitat conservation efforts, reducing pesticide use, and reporting any illegal hunting or disturbance of their nests. Educating others about the importance of these birds and their role in the environment is also essential.

14. Are Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks protected under the law?

Both species are protected under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, which prohibits the hunting, capturing, or killing of these birds without a permit. Violations of this law can result in fines and penalties for those found in violation.

15. What can I do to attract Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks to my property?

Creating a habitat with trees, shrubs, and open spaces can attract these birds, as well as providing food sources such as bird feeders with seeds and suet. Offering a source of water for drinking and bathing can also attract these birds to your property.

In conclusion, Broad-winged Hawks and Red-tailed Hawks are two fascinating species of raptors that share many similarities, but also have distinct differences that make them unique in their own right. From their physical characteristics and behaviors to their habitats and hunting strategies, these birds of prey are truly remarkable creatures that captivate the imagination of birdwatchers and nature enthusiasts alike. By learning more about these birds and taking steps to protect them and their habitats, we can ensure that these magnificent creatures continue to grace our skies for generations to come.