Skip to Content

Can Landlord Charge Pet Fee For Emotional Support Animal


When it comes to renting a property, many landlords have strict rules in place regarding pets. However, in recent years, there has been a growing trend of tenants requesting to have emotional support animals in their rental units. This has raised the question of whether landlords can charge a pet fee for emotional support animals.

An emotional support animal (ESA) is a companion animal that provides therapeutic support to individuals with mental or emotional disabilities. These animals are not considered pets in the traditional sense, as they are not trained to perform specific tasks like service animals. Instead, they provide comfort and companionship to their owners, helping them to cope with their disability.

So, can a landlord charge a pet fee for an emotional support animal? The answer is not as straightforward as you might think. While landlords are generally allowed to charge pet fees for traditional pets, such as dogs or cats, the rules are different when it comes to emotional support animals. Under the Fair Housing Act (FHA), landlords are required to make reasonable accommodations for tenants with disabilities, including allowing them to have emotional support animals without charging a pet fee.

However, there are some exceptions to this rule. If the presence of the emotional support animal poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others, or if the animal causes significant damage to the property, the landlord may be able to charge a pet fee or even require the tenant to remove the animal from the premises.

Trends related to the topic of landlords charging pet fees for emotional support animals include:

1. Increasing demand for emotional support animals: With more awareness about mental health issues and the benefits of emotional support animals, there has been a rise in the number of tenants seeking to have these animals in their rental units.

2. Legal challenges: Some landlords have faced legal challenges for attempting to charge pet fees for emotional support animals. Courts have generally ruled in favor of tenants in these cases, citing the FHA’s requirement for reasonable accommodations.

3. Landlord education: As the issue of emotional support animals becomes more prevalent, landlords are becoming more educated about their rights and responsibilities under the law. Many are now aware that charging pet fees for these animals may not be allowed.

4. Pet-friendly rental policies: Some landlords have chosen to adopt pet-friendly rental policies that allow for emotional support animals without charging additional fees. This can attract tenants who require these accommodations and help to reduce conflicts between landlords and tenants.

5. Tenant advocacy: Tenant advocacy groups have been vocal in supporting the rights of tenants with emotional support animals. They have worked to raise awareness about the legal protections in place for these individuals and have fought against discrimination from landlords.

6. Emotional support animal certifications: There has been a proliferation of online services offering emotional support animal certifications for a fee. While these certifications are not required under the law, some landlords may be more inclined to accept them as proof of a tenant’s need for an emotional support animal.

7. Eviction disputes: In some cases, landlords have attempted to evict tenants who have emotional support animals without paying pet fees. These disputes can result in legal battles that are costly and time-consuming for both parties.

Now, let’s hear from some professionals in the field about their thoughts on whether landlords can charge pet fees for emotional support animals:

“As a property manager, I have encountered many tenants who request to have emotional support animals in their units. While I understand the importance of these animals for some individuals, I also have to consider the impact on other tenants and the property itself. It’s a delicate balance that requires careful consideration.” – Property Manager

“I believe that landlords should not be allowed to charge pet fees for emotional support animals. These animals serve a vital role in helping individuals with disabilities to lead more fulfilling lives, and charging a fee for them goes against the spirit of the Fair Housing Act.” – Mental Health Advocate

“I have seen firsthand the positive impact that emotional support animals can have on individuals with mental health issues. Landlords should be more understanding of the needs of these tenants and should not create unnecessary barriers to having these animals in their homes.” – Therapist

“From a legal standpoint, landlords must be aware of their obligations under the Fair Housing Act when it comes to emotional support animals. Charging pet fees for these animals may put them at risk of facing legal action from tenants who feel their rights have been violated.” – Real Estate Attorney

Common concerns and answers related to the topic of landlords charging pet fees for emotional support animals include:

1. Concern: Can a landlord refuse to allow an emotional support animal in a rental unit?

Answer: Under the Fair Housing Act, landlords are required to make reasonable accommodations for tenants with disabilities, which includes allowing them to have emotional support animals.

2. Concern: Can a landlord charge a pet fee for an emotional support animal?

Answer: In most cases, landlords cannot charge pet fees for emotional support animals, as they are considered necessary accommodations for individuals with disabilities.

3. Concern: What if the emotional support animal causes damage to the property?

Answer: If the animal causes significant damage to the property, the landlord may be able to charge the tenant for repairs, but they cannot charge a pet fee specifically for the animal.

4. Concern: How can a tenant prove the need for an emotional support animal?

Answer: Tenants can provide a letter from a licensed healthcare provider stating the need for an emotional support animal as proof of their disability and the necessity of the animal.

5. Concern: Can a landlord require additional documentation beyond a letter from a healthcare provider?

Answer: Landlords cannot require tenants to provide additional documentation, such as certifications from online services, as proof of their need for an emotional support animal.

6. Concern: What if other tenants are allergic to the emotional support animal?

Answer: Landlords may need to consider the needs of other tenants with allergies and find a solution that accommodates all parties, such as relocating the tenants or the animal to different units.

7. Concern: Can a landlord ask for a pet deposit instead of a pet fee for an emotional support animal?

Answer: Pet deposits are generally not allowed for emotional support animals, as they are considered discriminatory under the Fair Housing Act.

8. Concern: What if the emotional support animal creates a disturbance in the rental unit?

Answer: Landlords can address any noise or behavioral issues caused by the emotional support animal through their existing lease agreements and rules, just as they would with any other tenant.

9. Concern: Can a landlord require training or certification for an emotional support animal?

Answer: Landlords cannot require emotional support animals to undergo specific training or certification, as they are not considered service animals and do not have the same legal requirements.

10. Concern: What if a tenant falsely claims to have an emotional support animal?

Answer: Landlords can request documentation from a licensed healthcare provider to verify the need for an emotional support animal and take appropriate action if they believe the claim is fraudulent.

11. Concern: Can a landlord charge a higher rent for tenants with emotional support animals?

Answer: Landlords cannot charge higher rent for tenants with emotional support animals, as this would be considered discriminatory under the Fair Housing Act.

12. Concern: Can a landlord refuse to renew a lease for a tenant with an emotional support animal?

Answer: Landlords cannot refuse to renew a lease for a tenant with an emotional support animal based solely on the presence of the animal, as this would violate the Fair Housing Act.

13. Concern: What if a landlord has a no-pet policy in place?

Answer: Landlords with no-pet policies may need to make exceptions for tenants with emotional support animals, as they are required to provide reasonable accommodations under the law.

14. Concern: Can a landlord charge a cleaning fee for an emotional support animal?

Answer: Landlords cannot charge cleaning fees specifically for emotional support animals, as this would be considered discriminatory under the Fair Housing Act.

15. Concern: What if a tenant with an emotional support animal violates the lease agreement?

Answer: Landlords can address lease violations by tenants with emotional support animals in the same way they would with any other tenant, through warnings, fines, or eviction if necessary.

In conclusion, landlords generally cannot charge pet fees for emotional support animals under the Fair Housing Act, as these animals are considered necessary accommodations for individuals with disabilities. While there may be some exceptions in cases of damage or safety concerns, landlords must carefully consider their obligations under the law when it comes to allowing emotional support animals in rental units. By understanding the rights of tenants with disabilities and working to find solutions that benefit all parties, landlords can create a more inclusive and supportive rental environment for all tenants.