Skip to Content

When Can A Landlord Legally Reject An Esa?


Emotional support animals (ESAs) have become increasingly popular in recent years as more people recognize the benefits of having a furry companion to help with their mental health. However, not everyone is on board with the idea of allowing ESAs in rental properties. Landlords have the right to reject ESAs under certain circumstances, but it’s important to understand the laws surrounding this issue.

The Fair Housing Act (FHA) protects individuals with disabilities from discrimination in housing, including the right to have an ESA in their home. Under the FHA, landlords are required to make reasonable accommodations for tenants with disabilities, including allowing them to have an ESA. However, there are some situations in which a landlord can legally reject an ESA.

One of the most common reasons a landlord can reject an ESA is if the animal poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others. For example, if the ESA has a history of aggressive behavior or has caused harm to other tenants or their pets, the landlord may have grounds to reject the animal. Additionally, if the ESA is not properly trained or is not housebroken, the landlord may also be within their rights to reject the animal.

Another reason a landlord may reject an ESA is if the animal causes significant damage to the property. While some wear and tear is to be expected with any pet, if the ESA is causing extensive damage that goes beyond normal wear and tear, the landlord may have grounds to reject the animal. This could include things like scratching up floors or walls, chewing on furniture, or urinating in inappropriate places.

Additionally, if the tenant fails to provide proper documentation for their ESA, the landlord may reject the animal. Under the FHA, tenants are required to provide a letter from a licensed mental health professional stating that they have a disability and that the ESA is necessary to alleviate symptoms of that disability. If the tenant fails to provide this documentation, the landlord may be within their rights to reject the animal.

Overall, landlords have the right to reject an ESA if the animal poses a direct threat to others, causes significant damage to the property, or if the tenant fails to provide proper documentation for the animal. It’s important for both landlords and tenants to understand their rights and responsibilities when it comes to ESAs in rental properties.

**Interesting Trends Related to Landlords Rejecting ESAs:**

1. Increase in ESA Requests: With the growing awareness of the benefits of ESAs for mental health, landlords are seeing an increase in requests for these animals in rental properties. This trend has led to more landlords having to navigate the legalities of rejecting an ESA.

2. Legal Challenges: As more tenants push for their right to have an ESA in their rental property, landlords are facing legal challenges when trying to reject these animals. This trend has led to more court cases and rulings on the issue.

3. Emotional Support Peacocks and Other Exotic Animals: In recent years, there have been cases of tenants requesting to have emotional support peacocks and other exotic animals in their rental properties. This trend has raised questions about what types of animals can be considered ESAs and when landlords can legally reject them.

4. Emotional Support Animal Scams: There has been a rise in scams involving fake emotional support animals, where individuals falsely claim to have a disability in order to have their pet designated as an ESA. This trend has made it more difficult for landlords to discern legitimate requests from fraudulent ones.

5. Impact on Rental Property Market: The issue of ESAs in rental properties has had an impact on the rental property market, with some landlords becoming more hesitant to allow these animals due to concerns about potential damage or liability. This trend has led to more stringent screening processes for tenants with ESAs.

6. Education and Training: Landlords are increasingly seeking education and training on the laws surrounding ESAs in rental properties in order to better navigate the issue. This trend has led to more resources and support for landlords dealing with ESA requests.

7. Eviction Cases: In some cases where landlords have rejected an ESA and the tenant has pushed back, eviction proceedings have ensued. This trend has highlighted the importance of understanding the legalities of rejecting an ESA in order to avoid costly legal battles.

**Common Concerns and Answers Related to Landlords Rejecting ESAs:**

1. Concern: Can a landlord reject an ESA based on breed or size?

Answer: No, landlords cannot reject an ESA based on breed or size as long as the animal does not pose a direct threat to others or cause significant damage to the property.

2. Concern: What documentation is required for an ESA?

Answer: Tenants are required to provide a letter from a licensed mental health professional stating that they have a disability and that the ESA is necessary to alleviate symptoms of that disability.

3. Concern: Can a landlord charge a pet deposit or pet rent for an ESA?

Answer: No, landlords cannot charge a pet deposit or pet rent for an ESA as these animals are not considered pets under the law.

4. Concern: Can a landlord require an ESA to undergo training or certification?

Answer: While landlords cannot require an ESA to undergo training or certification, they can reject an ESA if the animal is not properly trained and poses a direct threat to others.

5. Concern: What should a landlord do if they suspect an ESA is not legitimate?

Answer: Landlords should request documentation from the tenant proving that the animal is a legitimate ESA. If the tenant fails to provide this documentation, the landlord may have grounds to reject the animal.

6. Concern: Can a landlord reject an ESA based on allergies or fear of animals?

Answer: Landlords cannot reject an ESA based on allergies or fear of animals as long as the animal does not pose a direct threat to others or cause significant damage to the property.

7. Concern: Can a landlord inspect an ESA before allowing it in the rental property?

Answer: Landlords cannot inspect an ESA before allowing it in the rental property as long as the animal is properly documented and does not pose a direct threat to others.

8. Concern: Can a landlord reject an ESA based on personal beliefs about mental health?

Answer: Landlords cannot reject an ESA based on personal beliefs about mental health as long as the tenant provides proper documentation from a licensed mental health professional.

9. Concern: Can a landlord evict a tenant for having an ESA?

Answer: Landlords cannot evict a tenant for having an ESA if the animal is properly documented and does not pose a direct threat to others or cause significant damage to the property.

10. Concern: Can a landlord charge a fee for allowing an ESA in the rental property?

Answer: Landlords cannot charge a fee for allowing an ESA in the rental property as these animals are not considered pets under the law.

11. Concern: Can a landlord require an ESA to be spayed or neutered?

Answer: Landlords cannot require an ESA to be spayed or neutered as long as the animal is properly documented and does not pose a direct threat to others.

12. Concern: Can a landlord require an ESA to wear a vest or identification?

Answer: Landlords cannot require an ESA to wear a vest or identification as long as the animal is properly documented and does not pose a direct threat to others.

13. Concern: Can a landlord reject an ESA based on the breed’s reputation for aggression?

Answer: Landlords cannot reject an ESA based on the breed’s reputation for aggression as long as the animal is properly documented and does not pose a direct threat to others.

14. Concern: Can a landlord require an ESA to be crated when left alone in the rental property?

Answer: Landlords cannot require an ESA to be crated when left alone in the rental property as long as the animal is properly trained and does not pose a direct threat to others.

15. Concern: Can a landlord reject an ESA if there are already other pets in the rental property?

Answer: Landlords cannot reject an ESA if there are already other pets in the rental property as long as the animal is properly documented and does not pose a direct threat to others.

In conclusion, landlords have the right to reject an ESA under certain circumstances, including if the animal poses a direct threat to others, causes significant damage to the property, or if the tenant fails to provide proper documentation for the animal. It’s important for both landlords and tenants to understand their rights and responsibilities when it comes to ESAs in rental properties. By following the laws and guidelines set forth by the FHA, landlords and tenants can navigate the issue of ESAs in a fair and legal manner.